Bombay High Court (Aurangabad bench) throws out OMR-tampering pleas; cost ordered
The Aurangabad bench of the Bombay High Court has dismissed four writ petitions filed by NEET (UG) candidates who had alleged tampering of their OMR answer sheets following the re-test conducted on June 21. The bench imposed a cost of ₹5,000 on each petitioner to be paid to the National Testing Agency (NTA), according to court sources and media reports.
Two of the petitions were dismissed on merit after the court examined the original OMR sheets and heard submissions from the NTA, while the remaining two petitioners chose to withdraw their petitions, sources said. The four candidates named in filings and reports are Soham Gavte, Atharva Jagtap, Hricha Prafull Deshpande and Rahul.
- Two petitions dismissed on merit after court examination of original OMRs.
- Two petitioners withdrew their petitions during proceedings.
- Court ordered a cost of ₹5,000 per petitioner, payable to the NTA.
One petitioner, reported as Soham Gavte, had contended that his OMR sheet and the official answer key would yield a score of 522, while the scorecard issued by the NTA carried 95 marks. The other petitioners — identified as Atharva Jagtap (from Dhule district), Hricha Prafull Deshpande (of Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar) and Rahul — had similarly alleged discrepancies between the marks they calculated by comparing their OMR sheets with the official answer key and the scores declared by the NTA.
The NTA told the court it had already responded to these candidates through the prescribed OMR challenge process and grievance mechanism before they approached the High Court. The testing agency also said it had individually emailed scanned copies of the OMR answer sheets to every registered candidate at the e-mail address provided at registration, sources added.
“Digitally manipulated versions of OMR answer sheets are in circulation,” the NTA warned in a circular, according to reports.
The agency, in a circular dated July 20, had cautioned candidates against making false claims of OMR tampering and said it was closely scrutinising complaints. The NTA asserted that some circulated OMR images were digitally manipulated or AI-generated, and that such false representations were being investigated.
The NEET (UG) re-test was conducted on 21 June and the NTA declared the result on 16 July, after which several representations were received from candidates alleging that the OMR answer sheet uploaded against their roll number or emailed to them did not belong to them, was interchanged, or showed a substantially lower number of answers than the candidate recalled marking. The NTA has denied any evaluation error in those cases it examined, according to the agency’s submissions in court.
| Action | Number of Petitioners | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Petitions examined on merit | 2 | Dismissed after examination of original OMRs |
| Petitions withdrawn | 2 | Withdrawn by petitioners |
| Court-ordered cost | 4 | ₹5,000 each payable to NTA |
The court’s order and the NTA’s responses are likely to be watched closely by the large cohort of NEET aspirants across Maharashtra, including those in Marathwada, where medical admission prospects are keenly followed. Local students and families who had been monitoring the re-test outcome and subsequent grievances will note the bench’s insistence that the agency’s formal challenge and grievance process should be exhausted before invoking the jurisdiction of the High Court.
Legal observers said the cost imposition signals a caution by the bench against court petitions that duplicate administrative remedies or rely on allegedly manipulated documents. The NTA’s warning about digitally altered OMR images underscores growing concerns about misinformation and misuse of synthetic images in high-stakes examinations.
As these matters proceed, students who believe their challenges were not properly addressed are expected to consider the remaining statutory and legal remedies available to them, while the broader candidate pool awaits further clarifications from the NTA on any remaining discrepancies reported post-result.