State-level workshop in Rohtak seeks to promote scientific temper against fraudulent claims
Rohtak — A three-day state-level workshop on “Scientific Explanation of Miracles”, organised by the Haryana Vigyan Manch in Rohtak, aimed to foster scientific temper, raise awareness against superstition and expose the methods used by self-styled godmen and tantriks, organisers said.
Prof Narendra Nayak, president of the Federation of Indian Rationalist Associations (FIRA) from Karnataka, was the keynote resource person at the event. He demonstrated and explained how several purported miracles are performed and warned that such acts are often used to exploit people financially and medically.
“Many such individuals are selling unverified medicines and products in the name of curing incurable diseases, thereby endangering public health as these products are neither scientifically validated nor officially approved,” Prof Nayak said, according to organisers.
Dr Ranbir Dahiya, a prominent leader of the Manch, said participants saw demonstrations and scientific explanations of multiple popular claims. The organisers listed the following activities that were showcased during the workshop:
- Mock surgery without incisions
- Blindfolded reading and apparent 'mind reading'
- Fire-eating and production of sweets
- Cutting and restoring a rope; ash emerging from idols
- Apparent levitation tricks and lifting a person with fingers
- Hypnosis and claims of seeing ghosts
Dr Dahiya said about 40 participants from different districts of Haryana attended the workshop. He and other organisers stressed that contemporary techniques used to mislead people have evolved — with greater use of social media and more sophisticated psychological methods — making public education more urgent.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Event | Three-day state-level workshop on "Scientific Explanation of Miracles" |
| Location | Rohtak |
| Key resource person | Prof Narendra Nayak (FIRA) |
| Participants | Around 40 from various Haryana districts |
Prof Nayak argued that the eradication of superstition depends on a combination of factors including scientific temper, education and improved healthcare facilities, the organisers reported. He cautioned that while older tricks could be explained relatively easily, newer methods — such as staged 'mind reading' and viral dissemination via social platforms — pose fresh challenges.
Satbir Nagal, another leader of the Manch, set out a future action plan: organisers said similar awareness programmes will be rolled out across all districts of Haryana to expose what they described as "fraudulent" miracle claims and to promote scientific thinking among communities.
Other speakers included Pramod Gauri, who addressed broader challenges facing the country and perspectives on India's future, and local Manch office-bearers who conducted proceedings. Secretary Krishna Vats led the session management, and those present included Ramesh Chandra, Ishwar Nastik and Dr Ram Kanwar from the Punjab Tarksheel Society, according to the organisers' list.
Organisers emphasised a public-health angle in their messaging. They warned that unverified medicines sold by purported spiritual healers can pose direct risks to patients because such products commonly lack scientific validation and official approval. The Manch plans further district-level events to increase public awareness and to equip citizens with critical tools to evaluate extraordinary claims.
The workshop in Rohtak comes amid broader national debates on regulation of unregistered remedies and on strengthening scientific literacy. Local leaders involved in the event said the Manch intends to maintain momentum through demonstrations, talks and community outreach across Haryana.