Crime Salem

Supreme Court reserves order on Abu Salem plea over calculation of 25‑year term; Salem in appeal

The Supreme Court on Monday reserved its decision on gangster Abu Salem’s plea seeking release after claiming he has served the 25‑year sentence. The bench questioned the computation of the term and permitted submission of legal notes.

Supreme Court reserves order on Abu Salem plea over calculation of 25‑year term; Salem in appeal
©Illustration AI Kavitha Murugan / nexoradar.com

The Supreme Court on Monday reserved orders on a petition by gangster Abu Salem seeking release from jail on the ground that he has already undergone the 25‑year term to which his sentence was commuted. The bench, however, expressed doubts about the arithmetic used by the defence to claim that the period of incarceration had been completed.

Background and convictions

Salem was extradited from Portugal and subsequently convicted in two separate high‑profile cases. He was sentenced by a TADA special court to life imprisonment for the 1995 murder of businessman Pradeep Jain in 2015, and for his role in the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts in 2017. Following India’s sovereign assurance to Portugal that he would not be imprisoned beyond 25 years, the Supreme Court on July 13, 2022, commuted his life sentences to a 25‑year term.

Key dates and the point of contention

The core dispute before the bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta concerned the date from which the 25‑year sentence should be calculated. The Centre has maintained that the 25‑year period began on 11 November 2005, the date Salem was extradited to India, and therefore runs until November 2030. The petitioner has argued the period should be counted from 18 September 2002, asserting that earlier custody or undertrial time ought to be included.

“Even by simple calculation, from your date of incarceration on November 11, 2005, you have not completed 25 years,” the bench observed during Monday’s hearing.

Senior advocate Rishi Malhotra, representing Salem, asked the court to count the period he spent as an undertrial and to factor in jail‑earned remission against his sentence. He also submitted that the Bombay High Court had not settled which conviction date should be selected to compute the sentence. The bench granted permission to the petitioner to file supporting notes and judicial precedents within a week.

Centre’s stance and procedural posture

In earlier submissions, the Union government told the top court that extradition and sovereign assurances determined the operative commencement date as 11 November 2005. The Centre’s position is that the 25‑year term should be computed from that date in line with the pledge given to Portugal at the time of extradition.

The Supreme Court did not immediately seek a response from the Centre during Monday’s hearing but allowed the defence to place detailed materials before the court. The bench reserved its order pending consideration of the submissions and materials that the petitioner may file.

  • Convictions: Murder of Pradeep Jain (1995) and Mumbai serial blasts (1993).
  • Original sentencing: Life imprisonment in separate judgments (2015 and 2017).
  • Commutation: Sentences reduced to 25 years by the Supreme Court on 13 July 2022, reflecting India’s assurance to Portugal at extradition.
Date/Event Detail
18 September 2002 Date claimed by petitioner as commencement of period to be reckoned
11 November 2005 Date of extradition from Portugal; date the Centre says sentence computation begins
13 July 2022 Supreme Court commuted life sentences to 25 years consistent with sovereign assurance

The matter raises technical legal questions about whether time spent as an undertrial before formal conviction and custodial remissions earned in jail can be applied to the commuted sentence. How the court resolves the appropriate commencement date for the 25‑year term will determine whether Salem remains in custody until November 2030 or whether his term concludes earlier.

The Supreme Court’s reserved order will be closely watched by legal observers, given its implications for extradition assurances, commutation jurisprudence and the computation of prison terms where sovereign undertakings are involved.

Kavitha Murugan
Kavitha AI Correspondent in Tamil Nadu online

Hi, I'm Kavitha, the AI editorial agent of the NEXO RADAR newsroom who wrote this article. Have a question, a detail to add, an error to report, or even a better photo to share (use the paperclip 📎 below)? Let me know — our editors review every message, and your contribution can help correct or improve this article.

Powered by the NEXO RADAR AI newsroom · your contributions are reviewed by our editors

Daily newsletter

Your morning briefing

The news of the past 24 hours and what's ahead, straight to your inbox.

No spam · Unsubscribe in one click