The Odisha government on Monday ordered the state Crime Branch to take over the investigation into the disappearance of two key inquiry reports, officials said. A first information report (FIR) was registered last month after an internal search failed to locate the Justice A.S. Naidu commission report on the 2008 killing of Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) leader Laxmanananda Saraswati and a Revenue Divisional Commissioner’s inquiry into the October 2016 SUM Hospital fire in Bhubaneswar.
FIR cites circumstances suggesting unlawful removal
The FIR, filed by the state home department, records that despite an extensive search the two documents were "presently untraceable at the CMO". It adds that the circumstances create a reasonable suspicion that the papers may have been "intentionally removed, retained, concealed, destroyed or otherwise unlawfully dealt with."
“The two reports are presently untraceable at the CMO. The circumstances surrounding the disappearance of these two reports create a reasonable suspicion that the reports may have been intentionally removed, retained, concealed, destroyed or otherwise unlawfully dealt with,” the FIR said.
The Naidu commission had submitted its report in 2016. The Revenue Divisional Commissioner’s report into the SUM Hospital blaze was completed in 2018. The hospital fire had killed 24 people after smoke spread through the intensive care, dialysis and emergency wards of the private facility.
Background and significance
Laxmanananda Saraswati and four associates were shot dead by Maoists at his ashram in Kandhamal district on August 23, 2008. The killings sparked one of the state’s worst episodes of communal violence, which left at least 38 people dead and resulted in widespread damage to homes and places of worship.
The missing reports relate to two separate but sensitive episodes that prompted official inquiries. Their disappearance has prompted alarm within the state administration and triggered a criminal investigation to establish how and why the documents cannot be located at the Chief Minister’s Office (CMO).
Probe assignment and recent investigative trend
Officials said this is the sixth matter assigned to the Crime Branch since the Bharatiya Janata Party-led government under Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi took office in June 2024. Earlier cases handed to the agency include allegations concerning custodial abuse and other high-profile complaints in the state, according to official disclosures.
The decision to place the matter with the Crime Branch aims to ensure a specialised criminal inquiry into whether the records were misplaced, unlawfully destroyed or otherwise tampered with. The agency will be tasked with tracing the chain of custody of the reports and identifying any persons who may have had access to them after their submission.
- Reports missing: Justice A.S. Naidu commission report (submitted 2016); Revenue Divisional Commissioner’s report on SUM Hospital fire (submitted 2018).
- Incidents under inquiry: 2008 killing of VHP leader Laxmanananda Saraswati; 2016 SUM Hospital fire that claimed 24 lives.
- Investigation agency: Odisha Crime Branch (case registered by state home department).
Officials have not publicly disclosed details of any initial leads or suspects. The FIR and the transfer of the case to the Crime Branch indicate the administration considers the disappearance serious enough to merit a criminal probe rather than an administrative audit alone.
| Document | Incident | Report submitted |
|---|---|---|
| Justice A.S. Naidu commission report | 2008 killing of Laxmanananda Saraswati and associates | 2016 |
| Revenue Divisional Commissioner report | SUM Hospital fire, Bhubaneswar (October 2016) | 2018 |
The state home department’s complaint prompted the FIR last month. Investigators will examine official record-keeping at the CMO, the transmission and filing processes for commission and inquiry reports, and whether any statutory requirements for custody and archiving were breached.
Given the high-profile nature of the events tied to the missing reports and their potential relevance to accountability in both criminal and administrative matters, the outcome of the Crime Branch probe is likely to be closely watched by political actors, victims’ families and civil society groups in Odisha.
The Crime Branch has not yet issued a public timetable for the investigation. Further updates are expected as the agency proceeds with evidence collection and interviews.