Noida: A Zero FIR registered at the Expressway Police Station in Noida against a local girl for allegedly using abusive language against Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a protest at Delhi's Jantar Mantar has drawn sharp criticism from the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), which called the criminal action "unjustifiable" and urged authorities not to target young people.
Party questions criminalisation of abusive speech
CJP spokesperson Saurav Das questioned whether the use of abusive language should attract criminal proceedings, saying such matters should not be turned into criminal cases. Das argued that while offensive language can and should be criticised, invoking the criminal law in cases that do not incite violence amounts to misuse of provisions and appears to single out individuals to create examples.
"Has using abusive language become a criminal offence in the country?" Das said, adding that the police should avoid misusing criminal provisions in cases involving speech that does not incite violence.
Das also pointed to perceived inconsistencies in the application of law, noting that several elected representatives face criminal cases yet are not subjected to similar action, and urged law-enforcement agencies and the government to desist from targeting the youth.
CJP founder raises standards question
CJP founder Abhijeet Dipke amplified the criticism in a video shared by the party, asking why similar legal action had not been taken against individuals he said are linked to the BJP’s IT cell and who, according to him, have used objectionable language against women online over the years. Dipke questioned whether there were different standards for different groups.
- A Zero FIR was registered at the Expressway Police Station in Noida in connection with comments made during a protest at Jantar Mantar in Delhi.
- CJP leaders argued profanity that does not amount to incitement should be countered with more speech rather than criminal action.
- Party leaders alleged selective enforcement and appealed for leniency towards young protesters.
Context and reactions
The FIR followed a CJP-led protest over allegations of a NEET paper leak at which a teenage girl allegedly used objectionable language against the Prime Minister. The incident has prompted multiple reactions across the political spectrum. Media reports include a social-media response from actor and BJP Member of Parliament Kangana Ranaut, who reposted an apology video attributed to the teenager and urged parents to guard children against what she described as leftist influences. Kangana wrote that the girl is "hardly 15" in the post shared on Instagram Story.
CJP leaders have warned that protests would resume if cases against students are not withdrawn. In separate public remarks cited in media reports, CJP founder Dipke said the party would continue demonstrations until the FIRs were retracted and indicated the possibility of larger mobilisation.
| Event | Detail |
|---|---|
| Protest location | Jantar Mantar, Delhi |
| Police action | Zero FIR registered at Expressway Police Station, Noida |
| Political response | CJP criticised FIR; party leaders demanded withdrawal; BJP-affiliated voices also reacted on social media |
Legal experts and rights groups commonly note that the threshold for criminalising speech in India centres on whether it amounts to incitement to violence or falls within other recognised offences; CJP leaders argued the case against the Noida girl does not meet that threshold and cautioned against setting a precedent that could chill dissent among young people.
The registration of the FIR in Noida and ensuing political debate highlight tensions between maintaining public order and protecting free expression during protests, particularly where youth mobilisation and charged political issues intersect. The police and courts will determine the legal course; meanwhile, the controversy has already become a flashpoint in wider discussions about speech, accountability and selective enforcement.
Reporting from Uttar Pradesh.