Bengaluru: The Karnataka High Court on Wednesday refused to quash a First Information Report lodged in connection with an alleged job‑fraud operation that purportedly extracted about ₹5.3 crore from aspirants by promising placements in various government departments.
Court sees elaborate façade of fabrication
Justice M. Nagaprasanna dismissed the petition filed by Shamshad Begum, 48, and her father M.A. Mansoor Ahmed, 78, who are reported to reside in Madikeri and Bengaluru respectively. The bench declined to interfere with the ongoing probe carried out by the Central Crime Branch (CCB) of Bengaluru City Police, which registered the case in 2025 on a complaint by Sangamesh Rachaiah Vastrada.
The allegations in the FIR, as noted by the court, describe the creation and use of fabricated appointment orders, bogus email IDs, counterfeit letterheads and purported training programmes to convince jobseekers that they had secured government posts.
"...the alleged creation of fabricated appointment orders, fictitious email IDs, sham training centres and non-existent government departments, all for the purpose of duping innocent and gullible citizens,"
The bench observed that the material on record paints a picture of a contrived scheme and said the case bore the hallmarks of being "false in one thing, false in everything" — a Latin maxim the court applied to underscore the purportedly uniform falsification across documents and claims.
How the alleged racket operated
According to the complaint placed before investigators, the accused represented themselves as holding positions in the Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC) Mahila Morcha — Shamshad allegedly as General Secretary and her father as Joint Secretary. The FIR asserts these claimed affiliations were used to buttress the deception and lure candidates.
- Applicants were reportedly charged between ₹4 lakh and ₹25 lakh each for placement assurances.
- Promised sectors included irrigation, health, social welfare and the Railways.
- Victims were allegedly sent to Kolkata and Maharashtra for purported "official" training after being given forged appointment letters.
Investigation will proceed, court notes
The High Court declined to quash the proceedings at this stage, saying the record presently disclosed sufficient material to warrant further probe. The court characterised the alleged modus operandi as a "meticulously choreographed design" that required investigation rather than premature judicial intervention.
Petitioners had sought quashing of the criminal case. The bench, however, found that the allegations involved documentary fabrication across multiple touchpoints — from email ids to appointment orders — and were not fit for summary disposal.
| Element | Allegation / Detail |
|---|---|
| Accused | Shamshad Begum (48); M.A. Mansoor Ahmed (78) |
| Complainant / Agency | Sangamesh Rachaiah Vastrada / CCB, Bengaluru City Police |
| Amount allegedly collected | ₹5.3 crore (across multiple candidates) |
| Amounts per candidate | Between ₹4 lakh and ₹25 lakh |
| Alleged methods | Fabricated letters, fake email IDs, sham training, false letterheads, non‑existent departments |
Implications for victims and next steps
If the allegations are substantiated after investigation, hundreds of aspirants who paid large sums for promised jobs could be identified as victims. The court's refusal to quash the case preserves the investigators' ability to examine documentary evidence, intercepts and witness statements, and to follow financial trails.
At this stage the bench has not commented on the merits of the allegations beyond finding sufficient prima facie material. The probe by the CCB will reportedly continue and may lead to further charges or additional FIRs if investigators uncover more incriminating evidence.
Persons who believe they were affected by similar schemes are advised to approach local police stations or the CCB with documentary proof, copy of payments and any correspondence. The court's decision signals judicial reluctance to curtail criminal probes in fraud matters where documentary fabrication is alleged.
Justice Nagaprasanna's order maintains the status quo and allows the criminal process to run its course while investigators evaluate the scope and veracity of the alleged racket.
Reporting from Bengaluru.