Patna, Aug 7: The Bihar government has told the Supreme Court that Panchayati Raj Minister Deepak Prakash may lawfully continue in office as he has been nominated to the Bihar Legislative Council, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said on Friday before a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant.
Bench asks state to file nomination notification
The three-judge bench, also comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, directed the state to place the nomination notification on record at the next hearing, according to the court proceedings reported during the hearing. The matter is being heard on a petition challenging Prakash's appointment as Panchayati Raj Minister for a second time despite not being a member of either House when first sworn in.
During the July 30 hearing, the top court had queried the state on the legal basis for retaining a minister beyond the six-month period permitted under Article 164(4) of the Constitution when the person was not a member of the legislature. The court observed that "it is a pure legal issue" and asked the government to explain "how are you retaining a minister beyond six months when he is not elected?"
"it is a pure legal issue" and "how are you retaining a minister beyond six months when he is not elected?"
Background and timeline
Prakash, son of Rashtriya Lok Morcha (RLM) president Upendra Kushwaha, was first sworn in as Panchayati Raj Minister on November 20, 2025, in the Nitish Kumar ministry despite not being a member of the Assembly or Council. After Nitish Kumar resigned, Samrat took charge as Chief Minister on April 15, 2026; Prakash was again inducted as Panchayati Raj Minister on May 7, 2026.
On July 31, 2026, BJP MLC Devesh Kumar resigned from the Legislative Council to facilitate Prakash's entry as a member, the filings in the case indicate. The state asserts Prakash has now been nominated as an MLC and therefore the constitutional bar does not apply.
Petitioner's contention
The petition filed by Rakesh Kumar Singh contends that Article 164(4), which permits a non-legislator to be a minister for six months provided they are elected to either House within that period, represents a one-time opportunity and cannot be repeatedly invoked each time there is a change of government. The petitioner argued that Prakash should have secured membership between November 20, 2025 and May 20, 2026, the six-month window counted from his first swearing-in.
Constitutional provision at centre of dispute
Article 164(4) is central to the case; it allows a minister who is not a member of the legislature to hold office for six months, on condition that the person becomes a member of either House within that period. The court will examine whether the provision can be availed more than once in the circumstances produced by successive changes in the state's executive.
The Solicitor General's submission that Prakash has been nominated to the Council seeks to address the court's concern about the six-month limit. The bench has directed the state to place the formal nomination notification before it at the next hearing.
Immediate implications
If the court accepts the state's contention and the nomination is upheld, Prakash would be entitled to continue as Panchayati Raj Minister as a member of the Legislative Council. If the court disagrees with the state's interpretation of Article 164(4), it may set limits on the practice of reappointment or require fresh compliance with the constitutional timeline.
- Key dates: First oath — 20 Nov 2025; Re-induction — 7 May 2026; BJP MLC resignation — 31 Jul 2026.
- Legal provision: Article 164(4) of the Constitution.
- Next step: State to file nomination notification before the Supreme Court.
| Event | Date |
|---|---|
| First swearing-in as minister | 20 November 2025 |
| Change of Chief Minister | 15 April 2026 |
| Re-induction as minister | 7 May 2026 |
| Resignation of MLC Devesh Kumar | 31 July 2026 |
The case raises questions about the interplay between constitutional safeguards, executive action and party manoeuvring to secure legislative membership for chosen ministers. The Supreme Court will consider the state's submission, including the nomination document, at the next hearing.