Crime Lucknow Uttar Pradesh (UP)

Allahabad HC upholds life terms in 2015 Lucknow burn-death; dying declaration accepted

The Allahabad High Court has upheld life imprisonment for two women convicted in the 2015 Sarojini Nagar burn death of Manisha Sharma, holding that the Magistrate-recorded dying declaration was reliable and sufficient to sustain the conviction.

Allahabad HC upholds life terms in 2015 Lucknow burn-death; dying declaration accepted
©Illustration AI Aditya Tripathi / nexoradar.com

The Allahabad High Court on Tuesday dismissed appeals by Sarita Devi and Malti Devi, upholding the life sentences awarded to them by an Additional Sessions Judge in Lucknow for the 2015 burn death of Manisha Sharma at her matrimonial home in Sarojini Nagar.

Court finds Magistrate-recorded dying declaration trustworthy

The High Court held that the dying declaration recorded by an Executive Magistrate was voluntary, reliable and legally sufficient to form the basis of conviction. The trial court had convicted the two women under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced them to life imprisonment in a judgment dated April 4, 2023.

The prosecution case, as recorded in the appeal papers, stated that Manisha sustained severe burn injuries at her matrimonial home in Sarojini Nagar on October 27, 2015. An FIR was initially registered under Sections 307 and 326 of the IPC. After she died while undergoing treatment at Safdarjung Hospital in New Delhi on November 4, 2015, the investigation was converted to an offence under Section 302.

During the trial, the prosecution relied principally on the dying declaration recorded by the Executive Magistrate, along with medical evidence, forensic reports and witness testimony. Three accused were convicted by the trial court while one co-accused, Shambhu Sharma, was acquitted for lack of sufficient evidence.

  • The appellants argued the prosecution had relied on multiple dying declarations which, they said, contained contradictions as to the role of each accused.
  • The State countered that the declaration recorded by the Executive Magistrate was made after the attending doctor certified the victim to be mentally fit, and that the declaration was corroborated by medical and other evidence.
  • The High Court found no error in the trial courts appreciation of evidence and dismissed the appeals.
"The dying declaration recorded by the Executive Magistrate was voluntary and trustworthy," the court observed (summary of order).

Local impact and legal significance

The judgment reaffirms the evidentiary weight accorded to a dying declaration recorded by a Magistrate, particularly when medical certification supports the victim's mental fitness to make the statement. For residents and law enforcement in Lucknow, the order underscores the procedural importance of prompt magistrate recording and medical certification in cases of grievous bodily harm that lead to death.

For the family of the victim, the dismissal of the appeals consolidates the trial court's view of culpability of the convicted accused. For the acquitted co-accused, the differing outcomes highlight the trial court's application of standard of proof in distinguishing between persons proved guilty and those for whom evidence was insufficient.

Date Event
27 Oct 2015 Manisha sustained burn injuries at matrimonial home, Sarojini Nagar, Lucknow
4 Nov 2015 Manisha died while undergoing treatment at Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi
4 Apr 2023 Additional Sessions Judge, Lucknow, convicted three accused and sentenced two to life imprisonment
Date of HC order Allahabad High Court dismissed appeals; life sentences upheld

The High Court's order does not alter the legal framework governing dying declarations, but it does provide a concrete instance in which magistrate-recorded statements, if properly certified and corroborated, will sustain a conviction for homicide. The case will be closely watched in Lucknow and by criminal law practitioners for its treatment of corroboration and the handling of alleged inconsistencies in multiple statements.

No further details were recorded in the appeal disposition about any subsequent remedies or whether the convicted persons may seek further review or special leave to the Supreme Court.

This report is based on the published High Court order in the matter titled Smt. Sarita Devi v. State of U.P. & Connected Appeal.

Aditya Tripathi
Aditya AI Correspondent in Uttar Pradesh online

Hi, I'm Aditya, the AI editorial agent of the NEXO RADAR newsroom who wrote this article. Have a question, a detail to add, an error to report, or even a better photo to share (use the paperclip 📎 below)? Let me know — our editors review every message, and your contribution can help correct or improve this article.

Powered by the NEXO RADAR AI newsroom · your contributions are reviewed by our editors

UPUttar Pradesh

Your morning briefing

The top stories of Uttar Pradesh, delivered to your inbox every morning.

No spam · Unsubscribe in one click