The Supreme Court on Monday issued notices to the Chief Secretary and the Principal Secretary (Home) of Arunachal Pradesh, directing both senior officers to personally appear before the bench on 24 August after the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) flagged difficulties in obtaining records for its enquiry into alleged irregularities in public works contracts involving firms linked to Chief Minister Pema Khandu.
Bench acts on CBI status report
A Bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta considered the status report filed by the CBI pursuant to an earlier order that had directed the agency to carry out a preliminary inquiry. The matter stems from a public interest litigation seeking a probe into allegations that several government contracts were awarded to companies connected with the chief minister's family and close associates.
After perusing the agency's submission, the court said it was apparent that there had been non-cooperation from the state administration in furnishing the documents required for the probe and therefore deemed it appropriate to issue notices to the two senior officials.
“The status report submitted on behalf of CBI dated July 17. A perusal of the same reflects that there is non cooperation on behalf of the state government with respect to furnishing records. We deem it appropriate to issue notice to the Chief Secretary and Principal Secretary (Home),” the court observed.
Orders to appear and produce explanations
The apex court ordered that both officers must remain present before it on the next date of hearing with their responses to the CBI report and to explain the reasons for alleged non-cooperation and non-compliance with the court's directions. The hearing on the matter has been fixed for 24 August.
The litigation was initiated by the NGO Save Mon Region Federation, which moved the court seeking a CBI or Special Investigation Team (SIT) probe into the allotment of public works contracts in the state. The petitioner contended that the state administration was being run like a private company by the chief minister and urged a thorough central agency inquiry.
What the CBI reported
In its status report dated 17 July, the CBI indicated that it was facing obstacles in obtaining records from the Arunachal Pradesh government that are necessary for conducting the preliminary inquiry ordered by the court. The Supreme Court relied on that submission in concluding that action was warranted against the state officials responsible for producing documents.
- CBI filed a status report on 17 July noting difficulties in securing records.
- Supreme Court issued notices to the Chief Secretary and Principal Secretary (Home).
- Both officers are to appear personally on 24 August with explanations and responses.
Legal and administrative implications
The court's direction to summon the state’s top bureaucrats underlines the judiciary's insistence on full cooperation from state administrations when central investigative agencies conduct court-ordered enquiries. Repeated non-compliance or failure to produce records can invite further judicial measures, including contempt proceedings, though the court has not indicated any such step at this stage.
The case centres on allegations of favouritism in awarding public works contracts in Arunachal Pradesh. The petitioner had asked for a probe by the CBI or an SIT into contracts allegedly awarded to firms linked to the chief minister’s family and close associates. The CBI was earlier asked by the top court to carry out the preliminary inquiry; the agency’s reported difficulty in accessing state records prompted the bench to summon the two officials.
Next steps
The immediate procedural outcome is the personal appearance of the Chief Secretary and the Principal Secretary (Home) before the Supreme Court on 24 August. They are expected to submit written responses to the CBI status report and explain the alleged lack of cooperation. The court will then decide on further course of action based on those submissions and the CBI’s report.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 17 July | CBI files status report noting difficulties in obtaining records |
| 3 August | Supreme Court issues notices to Chief Secretary and Principal Secretary (Home) |
| 24 August | Next hearing; personal appearance of both officials ordered |
The development is likely to sharpen political focus on the allegations and could trigger demands for further transparency in contract allocation in the state. It also raises administrative questions about the obligations of state authorities to comply with judicially mandated enquiries by central agencies.
Further updates will depend on the responses filed by the state officials and any additional submissions made by the CBI before the court on the next hearing date.